Online Store    
 Member Login    
 Contact ASCLS    
 Search ASCLS    

Summit on the Shortage of Clinical Laboratory Personnel
SUMMIT II
Appendix A Items referred to in the text of the Report
#1 By a recent (Jan. ‘00) count at the HCFA there are;
 
170,926
  clinical laboratories countable under the authority of CLIA’88
 
96,701
  of them are POL’s
 
70 %
  not directly regulated (various personnel and other waivers)
 
90 %
  of laboratories perform < 10,000 tests / year
     
  • POL’s
  • Small / rural hospitals / clinics
  • Small private lab
   
#2 The fiscal impact of our field is approximately;
  7.25 billion tests performed annually (1999 est.)
$14.00 = average cost (1997 est.)
therefore we are a $101.5 billion dollar businessembedded in a $ 1.2 trillion dollar business (general U.S. health care) thereby representing as much as 11¢ of each health care dollar
   
#3 The BLS (Bureau of Labor Statistics) estimates;
 
17 %
  growth rate in our field
 
14.4 %
  for all U.S. jobs
 
5-13 %
  actual vacancy rate in U.S. labs - 1988 *
 
9-20 %
  actual vacancy rate in U.S. labs - 1998 *

[* = From Castelberry, B.M., and Wargelin, L.L., ASCP Vacancy Rate Data,
Lab. Med.30:174-8,1999]

       
#4 For the period 1998 - 2008 the BLS projects;
 
53,000
  new jobs in our field
 
40,000
  vacancies (retirements, leaving the field, etc.)
 
93,000
  incremental positions to be filled
 
9,000
  per year
 
4990
  graduates from all of our schools (NAACLS est. for 1999)
       
#5 Data from SSCLP I - ASM Vacancy rates
  (current from ClinMicroNet survey of June, 2000)
 
Northeast 7.5 %
Southeast 8.8
Northcentral          7.4
West 6.4
U.S. 7.9
       
#6 The tens of millions (33.6 according to To Err is Human - National Academy Press, 1999) of patients admitted to U.S. hospitals each year and the millions more who have laboratory tests performed in other locations and for other purposes expect a certain level of quality. The professional organizations in our field feel a certain custodial responsibility for dealing with this situation.
 
#7 This sense of responsibility perhaps made sharper in definition by the events following from the passage and signing into law of P.L. 100-578, the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments of 1988. This modification of section 353 of the Public Health Service Act seemed innocuous at first and focused on technical matters of standards and personnel. In fact it significantly altered the foundation upon which our practice field was built. In the intervening dozen years we have found ourselves in a huge fish bowl with not only the hundreds of thousands of clinical laboratory professionals but also regulators, manufacturers, researchers, public health officials and many others. We have endured the trials and tribulations of the acts of Congress, the marketplace and reimbursement realities.  
       
#8 There do seem to be some knowable reasons for the instability in our pool supply;
 
  • Salary
  • Stressful working conditions
  • Opportunity for advancement
  • Availability of desired working conditions
  • Image of the profession
  • Risk of infectious disease
  • Legal liability

[reported at the CLIAC meeting of April 2000 from Greenberg, L., Report to Congress on Shortages of Clinical Laboratory Technologists in
Medical Underserved and Rural Communities, 1993]

       
#9 Components of problem being identified (Example of one work group)
 
IMAGE/PUBLIC RECOGNITION GENERATION X, Y
TRANSITION/DYNAMIC OF PRACTICE/HC      SALARY
NOW VS. LATER, LONG TERM TECHNOLOGY
MANAGEMENT ORIENTED CURRICULUM AGING WORKFORCE
DECREASED SCIENCE INTEREST RETENTION
SCOPE OF PRACTICE (limited vs. expanded associated associated curriculum)
DECREASED CLINICAL SITES DANGER!
FUNDING FOR PROGRAMS AND STUDENTS
DEMANDS OF ED PROGRAM EDUCATION/PROFESSION
REGULATORY ISSUES/COMPLIANCE OTHER OPPORTUNITIES
MARKETING TO PROSPECTIVE STUDENTS
SELF-SELECTION OF PERSONALITY PROFILE
       
#10 Those components grouped (Example of one work group)
 
  1. EDUCATION
  2. TRANSITION (combined) HEALTH CARE
  3. RESOURCES - FINANCIAL
  4. HUMAN RESOURCES
  5. TECHNOLOGY
       
#11 Draft solutions proposed (Example of one work group)
 

EDUCATION / ESSENTIALS

  1. Redefine Essentials
    • NCCLS Summit in September
  2. Establish different tracts for 4 yr. MT/CLS programs
    • 1st two years = Med Tech Core Curriculum
    • 3rd & 4th years = more advanced MT/CLS classes
      • [concentrations] - Mgt.
      • - Information Systems
  3. Crosstraining
  4. Value added restructuring of MT/CLS training to better prepare the professional laboratorian to respond to clinical concerns.

IMAGE

  1. All organizations should pool resources
  2. Promote the Profession
    ex. Web site open to the public to respond to concerns regarding what lab tests mean.
  3. Start promoting the profession at the grade school level in 5th-6th grade.
  4. Develop Education Module for use by K-12 teachers - all organizations should participate.
  5. Go for Grant money to accomplish some of these goals.
       
#12 The chapter headings of a DRAFT Strategic Plan identified
  I. Data Collection
    * to know where we are
  II. Marketing
    * to attract young people to the field
  III. Recruitment
    * early K-12, compete with other science disciplines for the "science-minded"
  IV. Financing of Education
    *support to fund scholarships, examine the whole structure of health professions education costs and their accounting, find our what the students need
  V. Profession in Transition
    * what will professionals in this field be doing in the next 7 yr.? * based on the above, how many do we attempt to prepare, for what rolls
  VI. Cooperation
    * how do we enlist the initial and continuing support of our fellow professional organizations (represented at the Summit and others) , philanthropic sources, governmental agencies (CDC, FDA, CLIAC, HRSA, etc.), educational institutions (colleges, hospitals, etc.) and others in bringing sustained and effective effort to bear on this matter ?  

 

Summit II, January, 2001 | Data Collection | Marketing | Recruitment
Financing Education | Profession in Transition | Immediate Action Items
Immediate Consideration | Appendix A | Appendix B | SSCLP Home

 

Copyright © 1997-2009  | The Society for American Clinical Laboratory Science  | Ph: 301-657-2768  | Fax: 301-657-2909
6701 Democracy Boulevard, Suite 300 - Bethesda, Maryland 20817